Showing posts with label mutualism. Show all posts
Showing posts with label mutualism. Show all posts

Wednesday, February 22, 2012

A word on contract law and property.



"The institution of private property, in the full, legal meaning of the term, was brought into existence only by capitalism" - Ayn Rand
Objectivist "Anarcho-Capitalists" who think of themselves as "more Rand than Rand", usually see Ayn Rand's flawed critique of anarchy and support of minarchy as inconsistent and probably think of her rejection of polycentric law as just her having a "mental barrier to entry" so to speak. This quote suggests otherwise. I think it suggests (correctly) that private property is an institution, a legal right that society needs to respect, and that there must be a legal monopoly enforcing it, so that all recognize it.

Because, in a minarchy, people are forced to recognize the legal privilege of private property. That is, if a corporation builds a factory near your community and is given the legal right to dump toxic waste in the lake nearby, you can protest all you like, but you are still forced to recognize the corporations right to own and use that factory, and your tax money is used to protect that legal institution.

But it's different in a stateless society, or, in a contract law society. A contract law society is a society in which law isn't created by state coercion, but by voluntary agreement. Contracts would be made between actors, and enforced by Dispute Resolution Organizations.* Much has already been said about how absentee ownership and private control of means of production might decrease because of increased cost of insurance and protection and other things under such a society, and that mutualist practices and rights would be more practical and desirable in such a situation. But another thing that we should keep in mind is, that nobody is forced to recognize private property.

Let's say Klaus wants to build a factory and claim private control over it. He lives in a contract law society. Klaus needs a few legal privileges in order for him to have an incentive to build it in the first place. First of all, Klaus needs protection while he's homesteading the land and building the factory, so that nobody steals or destroys the things he is building with. He will also need insurance, so that he can be compensated if that happens. When the factory is built, he'll need a contract with an arbitration agency fully protecting his new factory, as well as insurance for the now built property.

Now lets say that the communities that are close to were Klaus wants to build his factory are aren't very happy about what Klaus is doing. They are worried that Klaus's factory is going to use up too much land and natural resources, and thus create more scarcity, and weaken the economic position of all other buyers and sellers of goods, or communes and self-reliant communities for that matter. They are worried he'll pollute the environment and/or dump toxic waste the lake. They are worried that the workers he seeks to employ will be treated poorly. What can they do?

It's fairly simple. They can firstly, create a voluntary organization and network of people who are opposed to such contracts, and discuss ways of undermining them together, by boycott and other things. They can demand secondly, the right of knowing what contracts their Dispute Resolution Organization (DRO) sign. They could demand that the legal contracts and insurances related to property titles are official to all of the customers of the DRO. If these contracts are not made official, they will simply stop associating with the DRO and find another one that does. The demand will most likely be met, since losing that many customers would be harmful. 3rd, in a contract law society, people will not interact with someone who does not have a legal contract with a DRO, or legal protection of his property. If Klaus did not provide legal documentation to workers for the factory they work in, they would not associate with him, mainly because they wouldn't have any legal protection if something happens to them. Also, if Klaus cannot provide legal documentation to the people he is trying to sell his goods too, it is not likely that they will buy his products.

4th, Even if a contract is made with a DRO, even that still does not mean that the contract will be respected. If a DRO does recognize Klaus's right to his factory, the people opposed to it will join other DRO's and demand that they do not interact with the DRO that created Klaus's contracts. The DRO's protection of Klaus' rights to his factory thus become meaningless, since the DRO now can't interact with other DRO's and create contracts with them, which is one of the main functions of a DRO. Contract Law is a system of collaboration rather than a system of coercion. It is truly democratic in the sense that the people create the legal rights, non-violently and horizontally. Your right to make a contract with one man is your right to make a contract with everyone else, and your right to not make a contract with one man is your right to not make a contract with everyone and else. And so, if Klaus will is to create a factory, and no-one in the society he lives in is willing to create contracts for him to protect his factory, he will not, unless he is insane, invest in building a factory.

In a libertarian minarchy, protection of all property, regardless of what it will do to the rest of society, is guaranteed by the monopolistic state. If you homesteaded it, all in society are forced to recognize it. You have no choice but to acknowledge it, pay for it's protection, interact with it and be exposed to violence if you don't. All of this while it's doing things that may be directly weakening your economic situation, polluting your environment, mistreating workers, and it's all funded by your tax money.  This is what I oppose when I say I oppose private property. I don't mean to limit anyone's freedom to act or create by using violence, but I don't want to have a system where a society is disempowered by a legal institution they are forced to fund and don't have any legal way of counteracting.

In a situation where law is democratized, where your consent to a legal act that affects you is the only thing that makes the legal act valid, this doesn't have to happen. You and your society is in complete control of what legal rights shall be provided, all without using violence and aggression to limit a persons own freedom to act. The society together, voluntarily, without force, sets up a set of principles they all agree on, and decides who gets power through who they give it too, by contract. It's democracy, in it's purest form.

* Please note that I don't hold "a contract society" to be necessarily the desired state. We can build upon the concept of free contract and association beyond just DRO's and legal privileges, I will talk about this in a future blogpost..

Thursday, December 29, 2011

The Labor Theory of Value.


After reading the neo-mutualist thinker Kevin Carsons books, "Studies in Mutualist Political Economy", "Orginsation Theory" and his rejoinders to the Austrians straw men that rained upon him after publishing SiMPE,plus some posts on the swedish blog http//:mutualism.blogg.se I've become more interested in the LTV, or the labor/cost theory of value.










According to Wikipedia:

 The labor theories of value (LTV) are heterodox economic theories of value which argue that the value of a commodity is related to the labor needed to produce or obtain that commodity

According to some economic thinkers, especially those of the Austrian school, it is false, because it doesn't take subjective value and marginal utility in to account, (which according to Carsons "Austrianized" LTV is false).

They also use the so-called "mudpie" argument. It says that the LTV would mean that a pie made of mud, and a pie made of for example cherries would have the same price, since the same amount of labor was put into it. Therefore, since most people would rather buy a pie made of cherries rather than a pie made of mud because of subjective values.

Sure, the cherry pie has higher utility for the consumer than the mud pie has. No follower of LTV denies this, at all. But do they pies have the same value? The follower of LTV says "yes". The value, or the labor that was put into making the pie is still the same, and the person who made the pie would still charge the same. Just because the consumer would not PAY the producer the FULL VALUE of the mudpie, it does not change the VALUE of it.

Now, let's say there's a man who is extremely poor, and walks into the café where the mud pies and cherry pies are sold. If the mud pie required an equal amount of labor for the baker as the cherry pie did, and sets the cost as such, then the poor man would surely buy the cherry pie over the mud pie. If however, the baker finds a way to reduce the amount of labor needed to create a mud pie so much that the price would be virtually nothing, the extremely poor man (emphasis on the EXTREMELY) might consider buying the mud pie, just to have something to eat. Of course, most people are not extremely poor, and not to fond of mud pies, so it would largely be a waste for the baker to make them.

The labor theory of value does not deny that subjective value plays a part in deciding market PRICES, it only says that labor is the equilibrium value that price tends toward. Desire may affect the price of a good, but labor CREATES the value. We all desire oxygen, for instance, but even though air is high on our value scale, it doesn't have market value. That is because there was no LABOR involved with creating the air. Now, if we all ran out of air, Space Balls style, and labor would be required to produce air, it would have VALUE. The cost of producing the air would be a key factor to deciding the price of a good.

DESIRE does not create value. We desire a lot of things that we would not pay for in a market, as the aforementioned "air" example.

Kevin Carson writes on his blog:

.....the LTV and other production cost theories of value simply assert that the price of reproducible goods gravitates toward a "normal" equilibrium value determined by cost of production (which is nowhere directly refuted by the subjectivists, since their claim to have replaced cost with utility as the basis of value is based on a very specialized and artificial understanding of those terms, and not on their meanings in ordinary usage).
So, the LTV is not about asserting that people value mud-pies as much as they value cherry pies. It's the idea that price is dictated or gravitates toward production cost, and it does not deny that subjective wants exist.

Now, while I do not have the economic knowledge fit to defend the LTV on court at all, and I don't have any authority to say that marginalism is wrong and LTV is correct, I at least hope this made some of my marginalist friends think about. I'm not entirely certain of my analysis, I have some trouble grasping the economic language, especially in English, at times.